Bro. Keith Stockley's paper "Smoke and Mirrors" explores the challenges Freemasons face in understanding the allegorical and symbolic nature of their teachings. He questions why these lessons are often obscured, leaving many Masons unable to interpret the symbols effectively. Stockley suggests that the secrets of Freemasonry are intentionally veiled to protect them from the profane, akin to a magician's illusions. He emphasizes that true understanding requires diligent study and personal interpretation, as there is no singular correct interpretation of Masonic symbols. Each Mason's insights are unique and personal, forming a private understanding of the fraternity's deeper meanings. The paper encourages both new and veteran Masons to engage with these allegories and symbols, highlighting that reflection and study are essential for uncovering the true secrets of Freemasonry.
Keith Stockley – Australia
December 17th, 2025
February 28th, 2026
manual
symbolism and_philosophy
Paper 02/2007
Title Smoke and Mirrors
Author Bro Keith Stockley – Australia
We are familiar with the statement that Freemasonry is a science veiled in allegory and explained by
symbols yet the average Freemason is unable to penet rate that veil and is unable to interpret these
allegories.
Why are the lessons and teachings of Freemasonry explained by sy mbols when most Masons cannot
name but few of them and even then are unable to explain those they actually can name?
Why do we not explain the allegories and symbols in simple English that all may read and understand?
There are probably many explanations for this, but here are a few thoughts of my own.
Most of Freemasonry’s secrets are contained in the symbols and allegories related in its rituals. We do of
course also have passwords and signs. Many non-Masons may believe that they know most of these, but
such knowledge is of little use or value other than enabling them to attempt to pass t hemselves off as
Masons.
It would also be a strange if the profane had little or no idea of the contents of our rituals as such details
and information have been broadcast to the world in thousands of publicat ions and on thousands of
websites.
Yet, despite our aims and purposes being revealed to t he world in thousands of ways, I have yet to hear
one of the profane, including Dan Brown, attempting to interpret our allegories and symbols.
Veiling our secrets in allegory and concealing them in symbols keeps them from the profane, somewhat
like the magician’s smoke and mirrors. Unfortunately however, this system also keeps them from the
Masons who are, of course, entitled to know them.
This perhaps reveals one of Freemasonry’s greatest secrets in that the secrets of Freemasonry are only
meant for those who diligently search for them . This requires study of our allegories and symbols for
that is the only method by which you may know t heir true meaning; the only method of penetrating the
smoke and avoiding the reflective deceptions of the mirrors.
The new Mason may hesitate to interpret an allegory or a symbol, in case he errs in his interpretation, but
he need not hesitate for he will have lots of company, even from the veteran Masons. In any event, who is
there to say that his understanding or interpretation is wrong? There is no one single interpretation of any
symbol that can be truly said to be the only correct one.
I venture to suggest that the only correct interpretation so far as an individual brother is concerned is the
one he himself finds. This becomes to him one of the secrets of Freemasonry. None of the profane may
discover that secret because it is locked away in the heart of the individual brother.
Masonic allegories and symbols present the fullest opport unity for serious reflection during a life-time of
study. Such reflection and study are the only methods by which the real secrets of Freemasonry may
come into the possession of anyone.