In "Who Manages the Managers?", Bro Rabie Jarmakani addresses the challenges of maintaining quality and consistency across Freemasonry's extensive network of 8,322 lodges worldwide. He emphasizes the critical link between membership retention and Masonic education, advocating for a structured approach to ensure that all members receive the same high-quality experience. The document outlines the importance of decentralized communication and accountability among Grand Lodge officers, such as Orators and Program Heads, to enhance the effectiveness of Masonic programs. Jarmakani proposes implementing checks and balances to monitor performance in areas like rituals, education, and membership engagement. By fostering a well-informed and motivated membership, the fraternity can uphold its standards and empower individuals on their Masonic journey, ensuring that the teachings are consistently promoted across all branches.
December 17th, 2025
February 20th, 2026
manual
administration and_governance
Short Papers Competition 2009
© 2010 Internet Lodge and the author
Paper 10/2009
Title Who Manages the Managers ?
Author Bro Rabie Jarmakani– Nigeria
Imagine an international Corporation with over 8,322 o ffices spread over 34 countries worldwide with a
workforce of over 270,000. You are the CEO and you are charged with ensuring every office provides the exact
same quality product. Let’s now make things really interesting and insist that offices within each country achieve
the same standards set by you. Congratulations, you now Head, Quality Control - WorldWide.
grouped in 8,322 lodges. Lodges within the United Kingdom are grouped into 47 Provinces, and Lodges
meeting abroad are grouped in 33 Districts.’
The challenges facing freemasonry today are no longer a my stery; we all know that a direct correlation exists
between membership retention and Masonic education. Can it be as simple as that? One thing that
Freemasonry isn’t, is simple; the fraternity presents us with a journey filled with symbols, veiled in allegory, and
shrouded by mysticism.
But who guides us on this journey and how do we ensure all 270,000 are equally equipped for the journey? We
all know that any organization is as good as it’s end product.
To this end, the UGLE has promoted programs t hat provide powerful tools such as; Mentor, Orator,
Communication, Social Relations, Information Technol ogy and Charity. It also provides vehicles for
communication; one is the online magazine, Freemasonry Today.
Still, how do we ensure Quality is maintained? Who manag es the managers? How do we benchmark our
performance: rituals, education, membership retention, quality of initiates, effective Boards, etc.
How do we ensure that the high standards set by the Head Office are maintained at the distant branches? How
are these 8,322 offices empowering their workforce and promoting the teachings with the same zeal and
enthusiasm?
In the business world, lateral organizational arrangement s add value, manage the business and contribute to
strategic success but, conversely, they can make spectacular errors that can be very costly to the organization.
However, in many modern organisations where convent ional communication structures either do not exist or
are less formal, communication tends to be horizontal, between individuals and departments, rather than the
upwards or downward flow assumed to be the normal ca se. Therefore, the decentralization principle is
important as the central tenet of many business practices.
Decentralization of each and every program launched by Grand Lodge should therefore have a clear and direct
link with the respective Officers: Orators, Presidents of Boards, Mentor Program Heads, Communication
officers, etc.
Each and every Officer at Head Office should now be re sponsible for their effect on that final product in each
and every one of these 8,322 offices.
With an improved and decentralized communication policy, and the insertion of effective checks and balances
for each and every program, the end product readily becomes a well read, motivated, and driven Brother
with a clear sense of purpose. A Brother who, where ever he reside s, will be properly prepared for his
journey.