Bro David Joyce's paper, "What’s in Your Attic?", explores the often-overlooked artifacts stored in Masonic halls and the importance of their preservation. It highlights how items, once replaced or deemed redundant, can accumulate historical significance over time, as exemplified by the discovery of old wardens' columns, meal tokens, and an early transparency of a skeletal figure. The paper emphasizes the collective ownership of lodge property and the challenges of disposal, advocating for proper conservation and display of these artifacts. Options for managing such items include creating an in-house museum corner, donating to existing museums, or selling items for the lodge's benefit. Joyce warns against neglecting these treasures, as they may hold cultural and historical value that can enrich the lodge's legacy. The document serves as a call to action for Masonic lodges to recognize and preserve their hidden heritage.
Bro David Joyce
December 17th, 2025
February 26th, 2026
manual
uncategorized
Paper 07/2007
Title What’s in Your Attic?
Author Bro David Joyce – England
If you asked, “What’s in the attic?” at your Masonic Centre, they will probably tell you, “Not a lot”. If you
ask what happens to stuff that is no longer used, you might hear something like, “We use what’s in the
temple, and a few things from the lodge’s locker – just like we always have”.
But you haven’t always! Masons are great ones for presenting things, and this makes other things
redundant. The donor’s presence* ensures the new objects will be used, causing the old to be forgotten,
but they do retain an odd status. Whereas an individual may throw his own property away, lodge property
is collectively owned. How do you dispose of it?
That’s exactly what attics are for! Let’s consider just one Masonic Hall.
Nobody knew anything about a box containing two pairs of wardens’ columns. One pair was dated 1895.
The other turned out to date from the lodge’s founding in the mid-1700s. They make a double example of
things that no one wanted to discard in the face of replacements. The benefactor purposefully had a box
made to contain his new ones and the earlier pair. When they were replaced, they were put in the attic.
Now no one is left alive to tell of it.
A boxful of tokens became genuinely redundant when the Masonic Hall was built. Luckily, one elderly
member knew that they were meal tokens that were once given to innkeepers in exchange for dining.
They were intended to prevent overcharging, since a licensee would only be paid for as many meals as he
could present tokens. Despite being solid silver, they lay (almost) forgotten from 1905 until 2005.
An apparently rolled-up banner turned out to be an early transparency of a skeletal ‘death’, with his scythe
and other icons of mortality, painted onto translucent leather. It was replaced in the late 19th century with
an identical design, painted onto glass. Hindsight now shows that this was traced from the leather
original. The glass one is lit from behind, which suggests that the leather one was back-lit too, being
stretched in front of a light source.
Unfortunately, such discoveries need proper conservation and display. There are several options: you
might spend some money and create a museum corner ‘in-house’. You can donate things to museums
that already exist. You can even sell things for the collective benefit of the lodge. It is not only old lodges,
as in the examples, that have hidden gems. Lots of old rubbish (otherwise called art nouveau, or art deco)
has been replaced relatively recently with ‘modern’ items as wartime austerity gave way to increasing
affluence.
If you simply shove the ‘rubbish’ back where it came from, it will certainly outlive you, as it did your
forgotten predecessors. But, while you will indeed be removed from worldly knowledge, whatever you
might find in your attic will probably cause its increase!
*Make a pun of it if you really must!