Bro. Mark Edmiston's paper, "Who Was Jeptha?", explores the biblical figure Jephtha, whose story is integral to Masonic ritual, particularly in the Second Degree Tracing Board. Jephtha, a military leader of the Gileadites, is noted for his cunning strategy against the Ephraimites and his complex character, marked by both military prowess and personal tragedy. His narrative emphasizes themes of loyalty, diplomacy, and the weight of promises made to God, culminating in the heart-wrenching sacrifice of his daughter. The paper highlights Jephtha's commitment to serving his people, advocating for conflict resolution, and embodying Masonic principles such as charity, perseverance, and sincerity. By examining Jephtha's life, the paper illustrates the moral lessons relevant to Masonic teachings, reinforcing the importance of acting with reason and maintaining harmony within the community. Jephtha emerges as a multifaceted figure, representing more than a mere reference in Masonic lore.
Bro Mark Edmiston
December 17th, 2025
February 19th, 2026
manual
education and_development
Short Papers Competition 2009
© 2010 Internet Lodge and the author
Paper 29/2009
Title Who was Jeptha ?
Author Bro Mark Edmiston – England
Of the many characters within Ma sonic ritual, Jephtha is one who seems to appear from nowhere. He is
first mentioned half way through t he Second Degree Tracing Board lect ure and is revealed as a cunning
and successful military commander of the Gileadites. It was he who trapped his retreating Ephraimite
enemies into revealing their origin through the simple test of how they pronounced a certain word. We are
told that this led to King So lomon adopting that word as a “pw in a FCs’ Lodge to prevent any unqualified
person ascending the winding stai rcase which led to the midd le chamber of the Temple” . And
then........Jephtha simply disappears from Masonic history, almost as swiftly as he entered.
What, then, are we to think of Jephtha? A bit-part player? Why is he even mentioned at all? And just
exactly who was he?
His story is mainly contained in the Old Testament Book of Judges [1]. The Judges (of whom Jephtha
was one) were appointed tribal leaders of Israel in the time before the founding of the Royal House of
David.
To most masons, Jephtha’s notoriety is associated solely with that infa mous word. The biblical histories
paint a more detailed and slightly mo re complex picture of him, as will be seen. But even within our ritual
[2], we gain additional insights into his character and perhaps further clues as to why he appears. The
Additional Explanation of the Sec ond Degree Tracing Board gives us an account of the fall and rise of
Jephtha and the Ammonitish war which immediately preceded his battles with the Ephraimites.
He was poorly treated by his family, having been b anished from his homeland because he posed a threat
to the inheritance of his half-brothers following the death of their father Gilead:
“’Thinkest thou, who art but the son of a bond-woman, to inherit with us who are free born?’”
He overcame this setback quickly, becoming the leade r of a small army in his adopted country and, at
some later point, his notoriety as a general led to the Gileadites turning to him to command their army
when threatened by a massive Ammonitish invasion. Th e ritual tells us he struck a deal with the Chiefs of
Gilead that if he succeeded in defeat ing the Ammonites then he would become the Gileadites’ permanent
ruler. In this part of the history, his determination to do the right thing comes through clearly. When asked
to command the armies against the Ammonites, he could easily have refused and simply maintained the
exalted position he had achieved in the land of his banishment. The undoubted impending defeat of the
Gileadites would also have afforded some measure of revenge for his former banishment, if Jephtha had
been so minded. Instead he chose to serve his people in their time of need, achieving the greater good
in the process:
“Recollecting it was his native country and his brethren (although unworthy), who were in distress”...
Ruthless in prosecuting a war, his objectives were always to protect his people. Although he lived in a
violent age of perpetual conflict, his first instinct was to seek a diplomatic solution to a dispute rather than
simply opt for combat. Once he had accepted command of the Gileaditish army and reinforced it with his
own troops he entered into negotiation with the King of the Ammonites. The ritual informs us that he was
“desirous, if possible, to spare the effusion of blood”. However, this dialogue proved fruitless and he was
Short Papers Competition 2009
© 2010 Internet Lodge and the author
forced to go to war with calamitous consequences to the Ammonitish invaders. Later, following acts of
aggression by his Ephraimite neighbours, Jephtha “tried all lenient means to appease them, but finding
these ineffectual had recourse to rigorous ones”. Again, the diplomacy failed but he certainly gave it every
chance of success and made all efforts to avoid bloodshed even although the Ephraimites had signalled
their determination to destroy him and his people and hel p themselves to the spo ils of the Ammonitish
war!
The biblical account adds a new dimension to the story, missing from standard masonic ritual. Jephtha’s
military victory over the Ammonites was followed by tragedy. Prior to the campaign he made a solemn
promise to God that if he defeated them, the first person to greet him at his house upon his return would
be offered as a sacrifice. To his horror, on retu rning to his home in victory he was met by his only
daughter, dancing and celebrating. And although it may seem incredible from a modern perspective that
such a promise should be carried through, Jephtha di d so after giving his daughter a short reprieve.
Basically, he had made a solemn vow to the GAOTU:
“..I have opened my mouth unto the Lord and I cannot go back.”
Indeed, his daughter made no efforts to avoid her fate , agreeing with her father that a promise made to
God must be a promise kept. This represented yet another reversal of fortune for Jephtha, undoubtedly
the worst during his eventful life. This episode, in particular, has influenced many artists and was the
focus of Handel’s oratorio “Jephtha”.
So.... what are we to think of this man once we piece together the various strands of his history?
His life, with its various and undeniably extreme “ups and downs”, amply illustrates the symbolic
explanation of the mosaic pavement contained in the First Emulation lecture [3]:
“Today we may travel in prosperity; tomorrow we may totter on the uneven paths of weakness, temptation
and adversity”.
The lecture exhorts us as masons to “act as the dictates of reason prompt us, to practise charity, maintain
harmony, and endeavour to live in unity and brotherly love” whatever circumstances we find ourselves in.
The history of Jephtha provides us with examples of:
The importance of a solemn promise made to God
The need for reasoned debate and the avoid ance of conflict if at all possible
Perseverance in the face of obstacles and setbacks
Truth, sincerity and plain dealing
And...most importantly, charity and relief. Jephtha came to the aid of his people when the easiest option
by far would have been to refuse. He also avoided the temptation of revenge.
Put simply, Jephtha’s story illuminates many of our Masonic principles.
............He is certainly more than just a “one word wonder”.
[1] VSL, OT, Judges, Chapters 11, 12.
[2] Emulation Ritual, 11
th Edition, 2005, Lewis Masonic.
[3] The Lectures of the Three Degrees in Craft Masonry, 2000, Ian Allan Publishing.