Bro Tony Barstow's paper "Darkness Visible" explores the interplay between light and darkness in Masonic ritual, drawing on literary references from John Milton and Alexander Pope. It highlights the significance of darkness in the third degree ceremony, where both the candidate and Brethren experience deprivation of light, symbolizing a journey into self-awareness and transformation. The paper connects this ritualistic experience to psychological concepts, particularly Carl Jung's assertion that enlightenment arises from confronting one's darkness. Barstow emphasizes the evolution of language in Masonic rituals, suggesting that the process of illumination is an internal journey, facilitated by intuitive faith and self-knowledge. The document underscores the importance of understanding the shadow aspects of the human psyche and the potential for personal growth through Masonic practices. It suggests that the collective illumination achieved in ritual can help alleviate fears, including the fear of death, by fostering a deeper understanding of oneself.
Tony Barstow – England
December 17th, 2025
March 31st, 2026
manual
education and_development
Paper 48/2007
Title Darkness Visible
Author Bro Tony Barstow – England
In his opening chapter of “Paradise Lost” (1674), John Milton seeks “to justify the ways of God to Man”,
describing Hell as “a dungeon ho rrible….no light, but rather darkness visible served only to express
sights of woe …where peace and rest can never dwell” whilst in the concluding verses, Man’s capability
for good is stated to be enhanced by his fall into darkness.
In his mock epic the Dunciad (1728), Alexander P ope challenges Milton’s Puritanism, describing the light
of reason as “one dim ray of light” and “darkness visible, so much be lent, as half to show, half veil the
deep intent”.
Walton Hannah’s book “Darkness Visible” (1952) parodi es the paradoxical juxtaposition by “exposing”
Freemasonry’s ritual to an uninitiated world.
In 1989, John Styron published his essay “Darkness Visible” in which his slide into depression is movingly
chronicled, reminding us of the Jungian descripti on of a journey into darkness- “ One does not become
enlightened by imagining figures of light but by making the darkness conscious”. ( C Jung 1954)
It may surprise today’s scholars of Masonic ritual that “Darkness Visible” is a registered trade mark (under
US and UK law) of Ross Heaven, an English therapist and author of several books on personal
development. His “Exquisite Darkness” is a series of three residential workshops in which adherents are
deprived of light to awaken an inner spiritual awareness and super consciousness –“stalking self
knowledge” is the laudable quest.
There seems little doubt that the wo rds of the third degree exhortation and charge intentionally echo the
poetry of Milton and Pope. Why? The candidate is again deprived of light but now so are all the Brethren.
By the “emblems of mortality” we might also understand the shadow side of our human psyche. As the
ceremony progresses to its climax, all our sensory forces are focus ed towards the single point of the
candidate being raised figuratively from death. Now we are reminded of an alchemical transformation.
Notice how the language has changed from the passivity in the second degree- “ Let me now beg you to
observe”- just as medieval al chemists were exhorted to use all their senses of perception, principally
observation rather than attention. The clarity of these spoken wo rds resonate in the darkness to
enlighten our very souls:- “Know then thyself, presume not God to scan; the proper study of mankind is
Man ” to quote Pope’s eponymous poem.
Whilst the light of reason al one is not sufficient, its “ glimmering ray ” begins a process of collective
illumination, growing in intensity, not from without –but from above or within- by intuitive faith or divine
inspiration born of self knowledge, bringing the as pirant especially ever clos er to the centre of his
microcosmos. By this poignant piece of ritual the fear of death in wh ich is constellat ed many of our
irrational fears and phobias, including the dark, is converted into glistering gold- “When there is a light in
the darkness which comprehends the darkness, darkness no longer prevails”. ( C Jung)